I know this is a little old hat, but I experienced the Miss South Carolina Phenomenon in a university classroom today. First, the stuffy background: So last week for my ethnology/anthropology course (Swedish Society and Everyday Life) we had been assigned various articles to read and analyze in preparation for discussion in this week’s seminar. We broke off into groups based on which article we had read to discuss the text and prepare a summary and some talking points for a larger class discussion at the end. A great majority of the class (myself included) had read a text titled “Medieval Selves and Current Communities: Playing with Identity at an Intersection of Rootedness and Mobility” by Lotten Gustafsson. The text covered the implications of folk heritage, medieval reenactment, cultural festivals, and role-playing on modern culture and our ideas of identity. We’d been getting into (what I thought was) a really interesting discussion about why people reenact history and why they do it to the point of creating an entire medieval persona to play at festivals and the like. There were some really interesting points about making personal connections to a place and to a history, something about reenactment that made the past more real, history as accessible, the boundaries of time, events as shared experience and what makes a place, the ability to create yourself in an entirely different light free from the bounds reality (a real world nobody playing the role of a king or other veritable importance, a wealthy banker safely and temporarily trying on the shoes and rags of a beggar). We even hit on some philosophy of play and entertainment and why people need to escape the simple grind of living. As a class, I’d say we drew some really cool concepts out of the text. And then it happened. The Miss South Carolina Phenomenon unfolding before my very ears: “I think that because of such things like war today people shouldn’t be playing role-playing games such as the medieval festivals or video games. I think with such problems today in the world this isn’t a good idea. Like games aren’t real. But those might be different issues.” The class went silent. I wish I’d been taking notes, for I have not done justice to the inanity we experienced. Only a reenactment. After a pause we continued on as if nothing had happened. Like we were all on a plane and it was about to crash so everybody just started having sex and then the plane righted itself back to safety and everyone got off like nothing ever happened. Yeah, that happened to our brains. Except without the good part. Only the atrocity. This is the reality people hope to escape through role-play.
For those of you who are somehow unfamiliar with the original phenomenon, or for whatever reason do not remember its occurrence, allow me to refresh your memories:
Listening to: The Lover, MMW
P.S. Oh, hello Proper Formatting. Where have you been?
Posted by Garrett Traylor 






